Democracy in America: When Citizens Vote vs. When They Choose Who Votes

Last updated 2 weeks ago. Our resources are updated regularly but please keep in mind that links, programs, policies, and contact information do change.

In Massachusetts, a town meeting is the local body that votes on money to run the town. At an open town meeting, the town’s voters cast those votes themselves. At a representative town meeting, voters elect members who vote on the meeting’s business. For a resident trying to change a spending decision, that difference changes the task: cast a vote on the proposal, or persuade the members who vote on it.

The same distinction helps explain American democracy. The United States is primarily a representative democracy: citizens elect officials to govern, while some state and local procedures let them decide particular questions directly. So winning an election decides who gets to make a decision, not what the decision will be.

A republic can also be a democracy

The Constitution begins with “We the People” establishing the government’s basic framework. It assigns federal legislative power to Congress, consisting of the House of Representatives and the Senate. Authority comes from the people, and elected lawmakers exercise it.

The Constitution also guarantees each state a republican form of government. James Madison was a co-author of the Federalist essays, which argued for adopting the Constitution. James Madison used the word in Federalist No. 10, an essay that appeared in the New York Packet on November 23, 1787, to mean a government in which representation takes place. A representative democracy fits that meaning, so calling the United States a republic does not make it any less a democracy.

The essay said a republic differs from a pure democracy in two ways: government is delegated to a small number of citizens elected by the rest, and a republic can extend over more citizens and a larger territory. It argued that a chosen body could refine public views, but warned that representatives could obtain votes and then betray the people’s interests. That argument identifies a recurring bargain: representation gives officials room to judge, while making their judgment something voters must evaluate.

Federal, state and local elections choose different powers

House members are chosen by the people of the states every two years. Under the Seventeenth Amendment, each state has two senators elected by its people for six-year terms. The amendment also permits states to authorize temporary appointments when a Senate seat becomes vacant, pending an election. So a senator can hold a seat for a time without having been elected to it.

The Electoral College is the process for electing the president and vice president, with electors casting the votes. Presidential general elections occur every four years, and a vote for a presidential candidate is a vote for that candidate’s preferred electors. Most states award all their electors to the winner of the state popular vote, while Maine and Nebraska use different allocation systems.

State and local ballots can include legislators, county council members, governors, county executives, mayors and judges, depending on the jurisdiction. Local legislative officials can make decisions about budgets, zoning, land use and tax rates. Voting is not limited to choosing a president: an office closer to home may control the particular decision a resident cares about.

At the federal level, Congress makes up the legislative branch, the president leads the executive branch, and courts interpret and apply laws and assess their constitutionality. The Constitution provides for the president to nominate Supreme Court judges and appoint them with the Senate’s advice and consent. Under the Tenth Amendment, powers that the Constitution neither gives to the federal government nor denies to the states are reserved to the states or to the people. No single election fills every government position or transfers every public decision to one winner.

Representatives vote as officeholders, not as automatic party ballots

A federal bill must pass the House and Senate in the same form before it goes to the president. Congressional committee hearings can solicit feedback and questions, while a markup lets committee members offer and vote on amendments. A committee can take further action on a bill without holding a hearing. Winning an election does not make one member’s preferred proposal a law.

The president can sign a bill or return it with objections, and Congress can override a veto with two-thirds votes in both chambers.

Congress uses voice votes and division or standing votes that do not record how each member voted by name. House roll-call tallies are posted online after votes, and Senate roll-call tallies are also available online. A recorded vote can show whether a member supported a proposal; a party label alone cannot answer that question.

Senate party whips are assistant party leaders who count supporters and gather party members for votes. Party leaders seek support, but individual officeholders cast the votes. Each takes an oath to the Constitution: Article VI requires senators and representatives to swear or affirm their support for it. A lawmaker’s duty to the constitutional framework is different from a party’s preference on a bill.

Political scientists distinguish a delegate model, in which representatives seek to enact constituents’ wishes, from a trustee model, in which they use judgment on constituents’ behalf. This explains why choosing a representative is not the same as instructing that person’s vote on every future issue.

Ballot measures let voters decide a defined proposal

A citizen initiative can place a proposed statute, or in some states a constitutional amendment, on the ballot. Here, citizens are trying to decide the content of a rule, rather than simply choose the person who will consider it. Initiative processes vary by state and are not available in every state.

In a direct initiative process, a qualifying proposal goes straight to the ballot. An indirect initiative first goes to the legislature, which may adopt it or a substantially similar measure without a popular vote. If the legislature does not adopt it, the question goes on the ballot under procedures that vary by state, and some states allow a competing legislative proposal alongside the initiative.

In California, for example, the steps are drafting the proposal, requesting a circulating title and summary, preparing petitions, gathering and submitting signatures, and verifying the signatures. Once the signatures are verified and the initiative is eligible, the secretary of state certifies that it is qualified for the ballot. A California initiative approved by a majority generally takes effect on the fifth day after the secretary of state certifies the results, unless the measure provides otherwise. California lawmakers generally need voter approval to amend or repeal an initiative statute, unless the initiative itself allows them to act without that approval.

A popular referendum uses petitions to put approval or repeal of a law passed by the legislature before voters. A legislative referral puts a measure before voters through the legislature, while an advisory referendum gauges opinion and has a non-binding result.

Where state or local law authorizes recall, voters can remove and replace eligible officials before their terms end. A recall decides whether a person stays in office; it does not pass or repeal a law.

A town meeting makes the distinction visible

In an open Massachusetts town meeting, all of the town’s voters may vote on the matters before the meeting. Town meetings in the state decide appropriations to run the town, elected officials’ salaries and local bylaws.

In a Massachusetts representative town meeting, the town’s voters elect Town Meeting Members, who then conduct the meeting’s business and vote on it. An open meeting gives eligible voters the decision itself; a representative meeting gives them the choice of the people who make it.

Eligibility and constitutional limits apply to direct votes too

Voters in federal, state and local elections must be U.S. citizens, meet their state’s residency requirements, be eighteen on or before Election Day and be registered by their state’s deadline. Noncitizens, including permanent legal residents, cannot vote in federal, state and most local elections. There are exceptions: some areas allow noncitizens to vote in local elections only, and some states let seventeen-year-olds who will be eighteen by Election Day vote in primaries. North Dakota does not require voter registration. Other restrictions, including those related to criminal convictions, vary by state. Direct democracy describes how decisions are made; it does not erase eligibility rules or mean every person present can cast a ballot.

The Fifteenth Amendment prohibits denying or abridging citizens’ voting rights on account of race, color or previous condition of servitude. The Nineteenth Amendment prohibits that discrimination on account of sex. The Twenty-Sixth Amendment protects citizens eighteen or older against denial or abridgment of their voting rights on account of age.

The Constitution and federal laws made pursuant to it are supreme over conflicting state law. A majority’s approval does not make a conflicting state rule constitutionally valid.

Follow the decision between elections

USA.gov provides a directory of state and local election offices for help with registering, voting and results. Check the election office for the offices and measures on the ballot, the applicable deadlines and the local voting rules. Check, too, whether a measure is binding or only advisory.

USA.gov also provides contact paths for federal, state and local elected officials. The House website offers a Find Your Representative tool and directs constituents to the member’s contact form to share their views. Send a request to the officeholder who can actually make the decision in question.

When a federal agency proposes a rule, Regulations.gov keeps the rulemaking materials in a folder called a docket and lets members of the public find the proposed rule and submit a comment. A comment is an opportunity to influence an agency’s work, rather than a ballot that enacts the rule.