Last updated 1 week ago. Our resources are updated regularly but please keep in mind that links, programs, policies, and contact information do change.
When disaster strikes, two names consistently come up: FEMA and the American Red Cross. While both are vital to the nation’s response and recovery, they are fundamentally different organizations with distinct missions, funding, and roles.
One is a core agency of the U.S. government. The other is a non-profit humanitarian organization with a special relationship to it. Understanding these differences is useful for disaster survivors, volunteers, and donors.
This guide explains who they are, how they operate, what they do, and how to get help from each.
FEMA: The Federal Government’s Coordinator
A Federal Agency
The Federal Emergency Management Agency is a key agency within the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. It is a formal part of the federal government, employing over 20,000 people nationwide, with a headquarters in Washington, D.C., and 10 regional offices designed to coordinate with state and local partners. During major disasters, its workforce can surge to more than 50,000 personnel to manage the response.
FEMA’s creation on April 1, 1979, by an Executive Order from President Jimmy Carter, was a direct effort to centralize a deeply fragmented federal disaster response system. Before FEMA, over 100 different federal agencies had some role in disaster relief, creating confusion and inefficiency for state and local governments. The National Governor’s Association specifically requested a single, centralized federal agency to serve as a clear point of contact, a request that led directly to FEMA’s formation.
While the agency is relatively modern, the history of federal disaster legislation is not. It dates back to an 1803 act of Congress that provided assistance to a New Hampshire town devastated by a fire.
Core Mission: To Lead and Coordinate
FEMA’s official mission is “helping people before, during and after disasters.” However, its primary function is not to act as a first responder. Its core purpose is to coordinate the entire federal government’s response when a disaster overwhelms the capacity of state, local, tribal, and territorial governments.
When a major disaster is declared, FEMA marshals the resources of other federal agencies—such as the U.S. Coast Guard for search and rescue, the Department of Defense for logistical support, and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for public works and debris removal—and directs them to support the state-led response. It is the conductor of the federal orchestra, not the first-chair violin.
Funding Source: The U.S. Treasury
As a government agency, FEMA is funded by U.S. taxpayers through appropriations made by Congress. Its primary financial engine for disaster relief is the Disaster Relief Fund, a major account it manages that is periodically replenished by Congress. The DRF is the source of funding for the vast majority of federal disaster assistance provided under the Stafford Act.
A crucial distinction: FEMA does not solicit or accept public donations for disaster relief. Its operations are funded by the U.S. Treasury.
Legal Authority: The Stafford Act
FEMA’s power and responsibilities are primarily defined by the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act. This foundational law governs almost all federal disaster response in the United States and provides the statutory authority for FEMA to deliver its assistance programs.
The Stafford Act establishes a critical activation trigger: FEMA’s full suite of assistance can only be unlocked after the President of the United States issues a “Major Disaster Declaration” or an “Emergency Declaration.” This declaration is not automatic. It must be formally requested by the governor of a state or the chief executive of a tribal nation. The request must certify that the disaster’s severity and magnitude are beyond the capabilities of the state and its local governments to handle alone.
This formal, multi-step process is the legal key that opens access to the Disaster Relief Fund and the wide range of federal assistance that FEMA coordinates.
This legal and operational structure is the primary reason FEMA’s role is complementary to, rather than redundant with, organizations like the Red Cross. The Stafford Act’s requirement for a formal request after local capacity is overwhelmed creates a built-in, legally mandated delay between the moment a disaster strikes and the moment FEMA’s full financial and logistical power is activated.
This inherent lag time is not a flaw in the system but a feature of its design, reflecting the constitutional principle of tiered response, where incidents are handled at the lowest possible jurisdictional level. The public perception of FEMA being “slow” often stems from a misunderstanding of this fundamental, legally-defined role as a high-level coordinator that must be formally requested and activated, rather than an immediate, on-the-ground responder.
The American Red Cross: The Nation’s Humanitarian Partner
A Non-Profit Organization
The American Red Cross is a non-profit, tax-exempt, 501(c)(3) charitable organization. It is explicitly not a government agency, a point it consistently emphasizes to the public.
Founded on May 21, 1881, by the pioneering nurse Clara Barton, its mission is rooted in humanitarian service. The American Red Cross is a member of the global Red Cross and Red Crescent network and operates according to seven Fundamental Principles: Humanity, Impartiality, Neutrality, Independence, Voluntary Service, Unity, and Universality.
Core Mission: To Alleviate Human Suffering
The mission of the American Red Cross is “to prevent and alleviate human suffering in the face of emergencies by mobilizing the power of volunteers and the generosity of donors.” This mission is delivered through five main service lines: Disaster Relief, Lifesaving Blood (supplying about 40% of the nation’s blood), Training & Certification (e.g., CPR and first aid), International Services, and Support to Military Families.
Funding Source: Public Generosity
Unlike FEMA, the Red Cross is funded almost entirely by the American public. It receives the vast majority of its financial support from voluntary public contributions—donations from individuals, corporations, and foundations. A smaller portion of its revenue comes from cost-recovery charges for some services, most notably for the blood and blood products it provides to hospitals and for its health and safety training courses.
The Red Cross does not receive regular, direct appropriations from Congress to carry out its core services. However, under certain circumstances, it may receive government grants or contracts for specific tasks, and FEMA can reimburse the Red Cross for certain eligible mass care expenses incurred during a presidentially declared disaster, as authorized by the Stafford Act.
Legal Authority: The Congressional Charter
The American Red Cross has a unique and often misunderstood relationship with the federal government, which is defined by a charter granted by the U.S. Congress. First issued in 1900 and most recently updated in 2007, this charter gives the organization a special legal status.
The charter designates the Red Cross as a “Federally chartered instrumentality of the United States.” This is a special legal distinction that grants it certain responsibilities on behalf of the federal government but does not make it a government agency. The charter mandates that the Red Cross fulfill three key duties:
- To fulfill the provisions of the Geneva Conventions, such as protecting victims of armed conflict
- To provide support and emergency communication services for the U.S. military and their families
- To “maintain a system of domestic and international disaster relief,” a responsibility that includes specific, mandated duties under the National Response Framework coordinated by FEMA
This charter creates a unique paradox. It grants the Red Cross the legitimacy and access necessary to operate on a national scale alongside government agencies, particularly in disaster zones. However, the official-sounding title of “federal instrumentality” and its Congressionally-mandated duties simultaneously create the widespread public misconception that it is a government-funded and operated entity.
This has profound implications. It means the Red Cross must constantly engage in public education to clarify its non-profit status in order to secure the voluntary donations it needs to fulfill the very duties the government has chartered it to perform. Its ability to execute its government-mandated mission is directly dependent on its success in proving it is not the government.
Key Differences
The core distinctions between FEMA and the American Red Cross are best understood through a direct comparison of their fundamental characteristics.
| Metric | Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) | American Red Cross |
|---|---|---|
| Type of Organization | U.S. Federal Government Agency (within Dept. of Homeland Security) | Non-Profit Humanitarian Organization (501(c)(3) Charity) |
| Primary Funding | U.S. Taxpayers (via Congressional Appropriations to the Disaster Relief Fund) | Voluntary Public Donations & Cost-Recovery for Services (e.g., blood products) |
| Governing Authority | U.S. Executive Branch (President, DHS Secretary, FEMA Administrator) | Independent Board of Governors (operating under a Congressional Charter) |
| Primary Workforce | Paid Federal Employees & Contractors | 90% Volunteer Workforce, supplemented by paid staff |
| Activation Trigger | Presidential Major Disaster or Emergency Declaration (requested by Governor/Tribal Leader) | Self-activated based on need; responds immediately to events like home fires |
| Core Role in Major Disasters | Coordinates the federal response; provides financial assistance to individuals, communities, and SLTT governments | Provides direct, on-the-ground services: mass care (shelter, feeding), health services, and immediate assistance |
| Legal Foundation | Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act | Congressional Charter (36 U.S. Code Chapter 3001) |
Who Does What During Disasters
The complementary nature of FEMA and the Red Cross becomes clearest when looking at their distinct roles across the disaster cycle.
Before the Storm: Preparedness and Mitigation
FEMA’s Role
FEMA focuses on building national and community-wide resilience through large-scale planning and funding. It leads the development of national doctrine like the National Response Framework, which guides how the entire nation responds to emergencies.
It provides extensive training for first responders and emergency managers and runs national-level exercises to test capabilities. FEMA administers billions of dollars in Hazard Mitigation Assistance grants, which fund long-term projects like strengthening infrastructure, elevating homes, and improving building codes to reduce the impact of future disasters. It also manages the National Flood Insurance Program.
Red Cross’s Role
The Red Cross focuses on preparing individuals, families, and its own volunteer force. It runs community education campaigns like “Sound the Alarm” to install free smoke alarms and teach fire safety in vulnerable neighborhoods. It also provides disaster preparedness education for children through programs like “The Pillowcase Project.”
A huge part of its preparedness work involves recruiting, training, and equipping its massive volunteer workforce for specific disaster roles, and pre-positioning emergency supplies like cots, blankets, and comfort kits in disaster-prone areas for rapid deployment.
During the Response: Immediate Aftermath
Red Cross’s Role (First on Scene)
The Red Cross is designed for immediate, direct action. It self-activates and does not need a government declaration to respond. Within hours of a disaster, its most visible and critical role begins: mass care.
Volunteers open and operate emergency shelters, providing safe lodging, food, water, and hygiene items to anyone in need. Its fleet of Emergency Response Vehicles moves into affected neighborhoods to distribute hot meals and supplies. Its Disaster Action Teams, which respond 24/7 to thousands of local disasters a year (mostly home fires), provide families with immediate financial assistance for lodging, food, and clothing.
At shelters, Red Cross health volunteers provide first aid, emotional support, and help survivors replace lost medications and eyeglasses.
FEMA’s Role (Coordination Post-Declaration)
FEMA’s large-scale response machinery roars to life after the President issues a Major Disaster Declaration. This process begins when a governor assesses the damage—often with a Joint Preliminary Damage Assessment team that can include state, FEMA, and Red Cross personnel—and formally requests federal assistance.
Once the declaration is made, FEMA begins its primary role as coordinator. It activates the National Response Framework, a guide that organizes the federal response into Emergency Support Functions.
ESF #6 – Mass Care, Emergency Assistance, Temporary Housing, and Human Services is the formal point of collaboration. FEMA is the lead federal agency for ESF #6, meaning it is responsible for coordinating all federal support for sheltering, feeding, and other immediate human needs. The American Red Cross is designated in the NRF as a primary partner and the lead non-governmental organization for providing these direct services.
In this partnership, the Red Cross provides the on-the-ground services, and FEMA supports them with funding, resources, and logistical coordination when the scale of the disaster exceeds the Red Cross’s own capacity.
After the Response: Long-Term Recovery
FEMA’s Role (Financial Recovery Engine)
This is where FEMA’s primary role for individuals and communities comes to the forefront. Through its Individual Assistance program, FEMA provides federal grants to eligible individuals and households to help with uninsured or under-insured necessary expenses. This can include funds for temporary rental assistance, essential home repairs to make a home habitable, and the replacement of personal property.
Its Public Assistance program provides grants to state and local governments to rebuild damaged public infrastructure like roads, bridges, and utilities. FEMA also manages other recovery programs like Disaster Unemployment Assistance and Disaster Legal Services.
Red Cross’s Role (Human Recovery)
As immediate needs transition to long-term challenges, the Red Cross shifts from mass care to individual support. Trained volunteer caseworkers work one-on-one with families to help them create recovery plans, navigate the complex web of available aid, and connect them with other community organizations.
The Red Cross may also provide additional, targeted financial assistance to households with significant unmet needs after they have exhausted other options, including FEMA aid. Throughout this process, its disaster mental health volunteers continue to provide emotional support to help survivors cope with the trauma of their experience.
The two organizations operate on different timelines and with different “currencies.” The Red Cross’s mission is to meet immediate, life-sustaining needs with tangible goods and services—a blanket, a hot meal, a place to sleep. Its currency is direct, in-kind aid delivered in the “now.”
FEMA’s mission is to facilitate long-term community and individual recovery through the provision of financial resources. Its currency is primarily financial—grants and reimbursements that address the “next” phase.
This distinction is critical for managing public expectations. A survivor needs to know to go to the Red Cross for a cot tonight, and to FEMA for a grant to help pay rent next month.
How to Get Help
Navigating the aftermath of a disaster is overwhelming. Knowing who to call for what type of help is a critical first step.
When and How to Contact FEMA
Contact FEMA for financial assistance to help you recover after a Presidential Disaster Declaration has been issued for your area. This includes grants for home repair, rental assistance, and other serious disaster-related needs that are not covered by your insurance.
How to Apply
Online: The primary and most efficient method is through the official website: DisasterAssistance.gov.
By Phone: Call the FEMA Helpline at 1-800-621-3362. This line is available 7 a.m. to 11 p.m. ET, 7 days a week.
FEMA App: Apply through the official FEMA mobile app, available on your smartphone’s app store.
In Person: Visit a Disaster Recovery Center. These centers are set up in affected communities and are staffed by representatives from FEMA, the Small Business Administration, and other partners. You can find a DRC near you by visiting FEMA’s DRC Locator online or by texting “DRC” and your zip code to 43362.
Information You Will Need
To apply, be prepared with your Social Security number, the address of the damaged property, your current mailing address, a description of the damages, your insurance information, and your bank account information for direct deposit.
When and How to Contact the American Red Cross
Contact the Red Cross for immediate, emergency needs. This includes a safe place to sleep (shelter), food and water, emotional support, health services, and emergency supplies. The Red Cross helps everyone affected by a disaster, regardless of their citizenship or immigration status.
How to Find Help
Find Open Shelters: Use the online shelter finder tool on the Red Cross website.
Contact Your Local Chapter: For immediate assistance, especially after a home fire, contact your local Red Cross chapter.
National Hotline: For general inquiries or if you cannot find local information, call 1-800-RED-CROSS (1-800-733-2767).
Common Disaster Myths
In the chaotic environment following a disaster, misinformation can spread rapidly, causing confusion and hindering relief efforts. Addressing these myths is critical to ensuring survivors get the help they need.
Myth: FEMA aid is limited to a one-time payment of $750.
FACT: This is false. The $750 payment is part of FEMA’s “Serious Needs Assistance” program, an expedited payment to help eligible survivors with immediate needs like food and water. It is not the total amount of assistance available. Survivors may be eligible for significantly more aid for housing, repairs, and personal property after a full review of their application.
Myth: The Red Cross is a government agency and charges for its disaster services.
FACT: This is false. The Red Cross is a non-profit charity. All Red Cross disaster assistance—including shelter, food, and comfort—is provided completely free of charge, made possible by public donations.
Myth: FEMA and the Red Cross confiscate or block public donations.
FACT: This is a harmful and false rumor. FEMA, as a government agency, does not accept donations of goods. The Red Cross and other non-profits coordinate the distribution of donated goods but do not confiscate them. These rumors often arise from the logistical challenges in a disaster zone, where authorities may need to control traffic for safety and to allow access for emergency vehicles.
Myth: If you have insurance or are a renter, you can’t get help from FEMA.
FACT: This is false. Renters are eligible to apply for FEMA assistance for needs like rental assistance and replacement of essential personal property. Homeowners with insurance should also apply. While FEMA cannot duplicate insurance payments, you may be eligible for assistance for losses that are under-insured or not covered by your policy.
Myth: Receiving FEMA assistance will reduce your Social Security or other government benefits.
FACT: This is false. By law, FEMA disaster assistance is not considered income and will not affect your eligibility for Social Security, Medicaid, SNAP, or other federal income-tested benefit programs.
The spread of such misinformation has become more than just a communications challenge. It is now a significant operational impediment in disaster response. Red Cross officials have stated that the countless hours spent addressing malicious falsehoods divert resources away from their core mission of delivering relief.
Similarly, FEMA leaders have noted that these false claims are demoralizing to aid workers and can erode public trust, potentially discouraging eligible survivors from applying for the help they are entitled to.
Our articles make government information more accessible. Please consult a qualified professional for financial, legal, or health advice specific to your circumstances.
