Last updated 1 month ago. Our resources are updated regularly but please keep in mind that links, programs, policies, and contact information do change.
The rise of online education has created unprecedented opportunities for students seeking flexible learning options. However, the same digital platforms that connect students with legitimate universities have also become breeding grounds for sophisticated fraud.
Distinguishing a reputable online college from a predatory “diploma mill”—an entity that sells worthless credentials for a fee—has become increasingly difficult. These scams cost consumers time and money while potentially jeopardizing their careers and reputations.
This guide provides the official knowledge and government tools needed to make safe, informed decisions about online education. By understanding accreditation and the functions of key government bodies like the U.S. Department of Education and the Federal Trade Commission, anyone can learn to identify legitimate institutions and spot fraudulent ones.
Accreditation: The Foundation of Educational Quality
The cornerstone of quality assurance in American higher education is accreditation. Understanding this concept is the most important step in protecting yourself from educational fraud. It’s the primary mechanism that separates legitimate institutions from scams.
What Is Accreditation?
Accreditation is a voluntary, non-governmental process of peer review in which colleges, universities, and specific academic programs are evaluated against established standards for educational quality.
This process isn’t a simple checklist. It’s a rigorous and ongoing evaluation designed to foster continuous improvement. The accreditation process generally involves three key steps:
Institutional Self-Study: The institution conducts a comprehensive internal analysis, assessing its own strengths and weaknesses against the accrediting agency’s standards.
Peer Review and Site Visit: A team of faculty and administrators from similar, already-accredited institutions visits the campus (or reviews the online infrastructure) to verify the claims made in the self-study and assess the institution’s operations firsthand.
Commission Judgment: The visiting team submits a report with a recommendation to the accrediting agency’s commission, which is composed of peers and public representatives. This commission makes the final decision on whether to grant, reaffirm, or deny accreditation.
Why Accreditation Matters
For students, attending an accredited institution is critical. Accreditation isn’t merely a seal of approval—it’s the key that unlocks essential opportunities and protections:
Eligibility for Federal Financial Aid: To receive federal student aid, such as Pell Grants and federal student loans, a student must be enrolled in an institution accredited by an agency recognized by the U.S. Department of Education. This is often the most significant financial consideration for students.
Transferability of Credits: When a student wishes to transfer from one college to another, the receiving institution will almost always require that the credits were earned at a regionally accredited school. Attending an unaccredited institution often means that coursework and credits are worthless elsewhere.
Employer Recognition: Employers rely on accreditation as a fundamental indicator that a job applicant’s degree represents a legitimate educational achievement. Many companies will not provide tuition assistance for employees to attend unaccredited schools and may not recognize a degree from such an institution when considering candidates for hiring or promotion.
Professional Licensure and Certification: For many professions—including nursing, teaching, engineering, and counseling—state licensing boards require that applicants hold a degree from an accredited institution or a program with specific programmatic accreditation.
Assurance of Quality: Ultimately, accreditation signifies that an institution’s faculty, curriculum, student services, and financial stability have met a recognized level of quality.
The Government’s Oversight Role
A common point of confusion is the role of the federal government in this process. To be clear: the U.S. Department of Education does not accredit educational institutions. The United States does not have a centralized federal authority that approves or controls colleges and universities.
Instead, the government’s role is oversight. The Department of Education’s primary function is to formally “recognize” the private, non-governmental accrediting agencies that it determines are reliable authorities on educational quality.
The ED essentially accredits the accreditors, holding them accountable for enforcing their own standards effectively. The Secretary of Education is required by law to publish a list of these federally recognized accrediting agencies, which serves as the master list of legitimate quality-assurance bodies in the country.
This indirect but powerful system is the core of federal quality control. By tying access to approximately $125 billion in annual federal student aid to accreditation from an ED-recognized agency, the government creates a powerful incentive for institutions to voluntarily seek and maintain legitimate accreditation.
This complex, two-tiered structure—where citizens must first verify a school’s accreditation and then verify the accreditor’s recognition—is precisely what diploma mill scammers exploit to create confusion.
Key Oversight Bodies
Two organizations are central to this oversight landscape:
The National Advisory Committee on Institutional Quality and Integrity (NACIQI): This committee, whose members are appointed by the Secretary of Education and Congress, advises the Secretary on the recognition of accrediting agencies, reviewing their standards and practices.
The Council for Higher Education Accreditation (CHEA): CHEA is a private, non-governmental association of over 3,000 degree-granting colleges and universities. It also recognizes accrediting organizations and serves as a national advocate for academic quality and self-regulation.
Together, the U.S. Department of Education and CHEA are the two primary validators of accrediting agencies in the United States.
Types of Legitimate Accreditation
Accreditation isn’t a one-size-fits-all concept. There are two main types that prospective students should understand: institutional and programmatic.
Institutional Accreditation
This is the most fundamental type of accreditation. It applies to the entire college or university, signifying that the institution as a whole meets a comprehensive set of standards covering its mission, governance, faculty, student services, and financial health.
There are two main categories of institutional accreditors:
Regional Accreditors: The United States is divided into several geographic regions, each served by a specific regional accrediting agency. Historically, these agencies have accredited most of the nation’s traditional, non-profit, degree-granting institutions, such as state universities and private colleges. Regional accreditation is generally considered the most widely recognized and transferable form of accreditation.
National Accreditors: These agencies operate across the country and typically accredit institutions with a specific focus, such as career and vocational schools, technical colleges, or faith-based institutions.
The Distance Education Accrediting Commission (DEAC) is a critical example for online learners. The DEAC is recognized by both the ED and CHEA and specializes in accrediting distance education institutions, making it a key quality indicator in the online space.
While a perception that regional accreditation is “better” persists, the most important factor for a student is whether the accreditor is recognized by the ED and/or CHEA and whether the resulting degree will meet their specific goals for employment or further education.
Programmatic Accreditation
This is an additional layer of review that applies to a specific program, department, or school within an already accredited institution. It indicates that a particular field of study meets the standards of a specific profession.
For example, a university’s business school might seek programmatic accreditation from the Association to Advance Collegiate Schools of Business (AACSB), its nursing program from the Commission on Collegiate Nursing Education (CCNE), or its social work program from the Council on Social Work Education (CSWE).
For students entering licensed professions, ensuring their program has the necessary programmatic accreditation is essential.
The Dark Side: Anatomy of a Diploma Mill
While legitimate online colleges provide valuable educational pathways, the internet is also rife with fraudulent entities known as diploma mills. These organizations prey on student aspirations, offering the promise of a credential without the substance of an education.
What Is a Diploma Mill?
A diploma mill is an unaccredited or fraudulently accredited organization that sells academic degrees, diplomas, and other credentials for a fee, while requiring little to no legitimate academic work from the “student.”
The primary mission of a diploma mill is not education but profit. They are designed to take your money in exchange for a worthless piece of paper. The Federal Trade Commission, the nation’s primary consumer protection agency, has a long history of pursuing these operations, viewing their practices as unfair and deceptive commerce.
It’s important to distinguish diploma mills from legitimate unaccredited institutions. Some new schools may be in the multi-year process of earning accreditation, and some religious institutions may choose not to seek accreditation for theological reasons.
The defining feature of a diploma mill is not merely its lack of recognized accreditation, but the intentional element of fraud and the complete absence of meaningful academic standards.
The Harm They Cause
The damage caused by diploma mills is extensive:
- Individuals who are deceived lose their money and time
- Those who knowingly purchase fake degrees to secure employment or promotions risk being fired and may face civil or criminal charges
- Employers who unknowingly hire individuals with fake credentials may suffer from having unqualified employees and can be exposed to liability
- Diploma mills devalue the hard work of millions who have earned legitimate degrees and erode public trust in higher education
Red Flags: How to Spot a Scam
Diploma mills have become increasingly sophisticated in their marketing, with slick websites and professional-looking materials. However, they almost always exhibit a combination of tell-tale signs.
This checklist combines warnings from the Federal Trade Commission, the Better Business Bureau, and state attorneys general to help consumers spot a scam.
Promises and Pressure
“Quickie Degrees”: The school guarantees a degree in an unbelievably short period, such as a few days, weeks, or months. Legitimate degrees require years of study.
Degrees for “Life Experience” Alone: The school’s main selling point is awarding a full degree based solely on a review of your resume, work history, or life experience. While legitimate colleges may grant a limited number of credits for prior learning through a rigorous evaluation process, they never award an entire degree this way.
Aggressive Sales and Advertising: The school uses high-pressure telemarketing calls, unsolicited spam emails, or pop-up ads to recruit students. Legitimate institutions do not engage in these tactics.
Payment and Costs
Flat Fee for a Degree: The school charges a single flat fee for an entire degree program, often offering “special discounts” if you purchase multiple degrees (e.g., a bachelor’s and a master’s) at once. Legitimate colleges charge tuition per credit hour, per course, or per semester.
Academics and Faculty
No Real Coursework or Interaction: The program requires little to no actual studying, has no meaningful exams, and involves no substantive interaction with professors or instructors.
Vague or Nonexistent Faculty: The school’s website provides no information about its faculty, or the instructors listed have questionable credentials, often from other diploma mills.
Accreditation and Identity
Fake or Unrecognized Accreditation: The school claims to be “fully accredited,” but the accrediting agency listed is a bogus entity created by the mill itself to sound official. These are often called “accreditation mills.”
Sound-Alike Names: The school uses a name that is deceptively similar to that of a well-known, prestigious university to create confusion (e.g., “Columbia State University” instead of Columbia University).
Suspicious Contact Information: The school’s physical address is just a P.O. Box or a mail-forwarding service, with no actual campus. Often, no phone number is provided, or calls go to an answering service.
Misleading Web Address: A “.edu” domain is not a guarantee of legitimacy, as some mills have managed to acquire them. Many use commercial domains (.com, .org) or misleading academic-sounding domains like .ac (which is the country code for Ascension Island).
Comparison Chart: Legitimate vs. Fraudulent
| Characteristic | Legitimate Online College | Diploma Mill Scam |
|---|---|---|
| Accreditation | Accredited by an agency recognized by the U.S. Department of Education and/or the Council for Higher Education Accreditation | Unaccredited, or “accredited” by a fake, unrecognized “accreditation mill” |
| Admissions Process | Requires submission of official transcripts from previous schools (e.g., high school, other colleges) and sometimes standardized test scores | No previous academic records required for admission. Open enrollment for anyone who can pay |
| Coursework & Faculty | Involves structured courses, required reading, substantive assignments, proctored exams, and regular, meaningful interaction with qualified faculty who hold advanced degrees | Little to no coursework required. No real interaction with faculty. Degrees are essentially purchased |
| Time to Degree | Degree timelines are standard (e.g., approx. 4 years for a bachelor’s). Accelerated programs exist but still require significant, intensive coursework over a compressed period | Promises a degree in an impossibly short time (days, weeks, or months) |
| Tuition Structure | Charges tuition per credit hour, per course, or per semester/term. Financial aid is available | Charges a single flat fee per degree. Often offers “package deals” for multiple degrees |
| Student Support | Offers a wide range of support services: academic advising, library services, technical support, career services, and mental health resources | No meaningful student support services are offered. The focus is solely on the financial transaction |
| Recognition | Credits are generally transferable to other accredited institutions. Degrees are recognized by employers and state licensing boards | Credits are not transferable. Degrees are worthless and not recognized by employers or other schools |
Real Cases: Government Action Against Diploma Mills
The threat of diploma mills isn’t theoretical. Federal and state law enforcement agencies actively pursue and shut down these fraudulent operations. These cases illustrate the tangible harm they cause and the legal consequences for their operators.
Case Study: FTC vs. ‘Jefferson High School Online’
This case highlights a common scam targeting individuals seeking a high school credential. The operators of these “online high schools” took in more than $11 million by selling what they claimed were “official” and accredited high school diplomas for fees between $200 and $300.
Their deceptive tactics were extensive:
- They falsely promised consumers that these diplomas could be used to enroll in college, apply for jobs, and enlist in the military
- They used deceptive website metatags with terms like “GED online” to appear in search results for legitimate equivalency programs
- The “academic work” consisted of simple online multiple-choice tests. If a student failed a test, they were redirected to it again, but this time with the correct answers highlighted so they could pass
- Credit was awarded for “life experience” in a farcical manner; for example, stating that one “listens to music occasionally” could translate to credit for a music appreciation course
Numerous consumers discovered their diplomas were worthless when they were rejected by colleges, employers, and military recruiters. In 2015, the Federal Trade Commission successfully shut down the operation, froze the defendants’ assets, and permanently banned the owners from marketing or selling academic degrees.
Case Study: Texas vs. ‘Parkview Home School’
This state-level case demonstrates the long-running nature of some scams and their direct encouragement of further fraud. For over two decades, Parkview Home School, a Houston-based entity, sold fraudulent high school diplomas and transcripts, collecting approximately $1.4 million from Texas consumers.
The operation employed no teachers and required virtually no coursework. “Students” paid a fee of $200 to $300, were sent workbooks along with the answer keys, and received a diploma within days of returning them.
The most egregious aspect of this scam was that the operators actively coached their “graduates” to commit federal financial aid fraud. They instructed them to falsely claim “home school” status on their Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) forms, which subjected the unsuspecting students to potential criminal and administrative penalties.
The Texas Attorney General’s Office filed a lawsuit against Parkview for multiple violations of the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act, seeking to halt their operations and penalize the owners. This case shows how state consumer protection laws are a vital tool in combating educational fraud at the local level.
Your Verification Toolkit
Armed with an understanding of accreditation and the red flags of a scam, any citizen can perform due diligence to verify the legitimacy of an online college. This process involves using free, official resources provided by government and non-governmental organizations.
Essential Verification Tools
| Tool/Resource Name | URL | Sponsoring Agency | Primary Purpose |
|---|---|---|---|
| Database of Accredited Postsecondary Institutions and Programs (DAPIP) | https://ope.ed.gov/dapip/ | U.S. Department of Education | The definitive federal database to check if a school is accredited by a federally recognized agency |
| CHEA Database of Institutions and Programs | https://www.chea.org/search-institutions | Council for Higher Education Accreditation | A key non-governmental database to cross-reference a school’s accreditation status |
| State Attorney General’s Office | (Varies by state; search “[State] Attorney General”) | State Government | To check if a school is legally authorized to operate in its home state and to inquire about consumer complaints |
| Better Business Bureau | https://www.bbb.org/ | Better Business Bureau | A non-profit resource to check for business reviews, ratings, and consumer complaints against a school |
Step-by-Step Verification Process
Step 1: The Accreditation Check
The first and most crucial step is to verify an institution’s accreditation status using official databases. Do not simply trust the claims on a school’s website.
The Primary Tool: U.S. Department of Education’s DAPIP
The definitive starting point for any investigation is the Database of Accredited Postsecondary Institutions and Programs (DAPIP), maintained by the ED’s Office of Postsecondary Education.
How to Use It: Navigate to the website and enter the full, exact name of the college or university into the search field. If the institution is legitimately accredited by an agency that the U.S. government recognizes, it will appear in the search results along with its accreditor’s name. If it does not appear, it’s a major red flag.
Important Caveat: The Department of Education notes that the information in DAPIP is reported to them by the accrediting agencies and is not independently audited by the ED. While it’s the best single source, for the most up-to-the-minute information, contacting the accrediting agency directly may be necessary.
The Cross-Reference Tool: CHEA
To be thorough, also check the database provided by the Council for Higher Education Accreditation (CHEA), the other major validator of accrediting bodies.
How to Use It: Similar to the DAPIP, search for the institution by name. Checking both the ED and CHEA databases provides the most complete and reliable picture of a school’s accreditation status.
Step 2: Investigate the Accreditor
As diploma mills often create their own fake “accreditation mills” to appear legitimate, a critical follow-up step is to verify the accreditor itself. If a school claims it’s accredited but doesn’t appear in the DAPIP or CHEA databases, the accrediting agency it names is almost certainly fraudulent.
- Find the name of the accrediting agency on the school’s website
- Go to the U.S. Department of Education’s official list of recognized accrediting agencies
- Cross-reference this with CHEA’s list of recognized accrediting organizations
If the accrediting agency named by the school doesn’t appear on both of these official lists, its “accreditation” is worthless. Be wary of official-sounding names designed to mimic legitimate agencies.
Step 3: Practical Investigation
Digital databases are essential, but some practical steps can provide powerful, real-world verification. Diploma mills can create fake websites and fraudulent documents, but they can’t force legitimate institutions to recognize their credentials.
The Transfer Credit Test: This is a simple yet highly effective litmus test. Call the registrar’s office of a local, well-known community college or state university. Ask them directly: “I am considering enrolling at [school name]. Would you accept transfer credits from that institution?”
If the registrar’s office has never heard of the school or states that they wouldn’t accept its credits, this is an extremely strong indicator that you’re dealing with a diploma mill.
Contact Government and Consumer Agencies:
State Attorney General: Contact the office of the state attorney general in the state where the school claims to have its headquarters. Ask if the institution is legally authorized to grant degrees in that state and whether any consumer complaints have been filed against it. A list of state attorneys general can be found here.
Better Business Bureau: Search for the school on the BBB website. While not a government agency, the BBB compiles consumer complaints and can provide insight into a school’s business practices.
What to Do If You Suspect a Scam
If you believe you have encountered or been defrauded by a diploma mill, it’s crucial to report it. This helps protect other consumers and provides law enforcement with the information needed to take action.
- File a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission
- File a complaint with your state attorney general’s office
Hallmarks of a Legitimate Online College
Beyond simply avoiding scams, prospective students should know how to identify the hallmarks of a high-quality online educational experience. A legitimate online college is more than just accredited—it’s an institution committed to academic rigor, robust student support, and operational transparency.
Academic Rigor and Qualified Faculty
The core of any educational institution is the quality of its teaching and curriculum. Diploma mills focus on the transaction of selling a credential, while legitimate colleges focus on the process of learning.
Qualified Faculty: Legitimate online colleges are transparent about their faculty and their qualifications. Professors and instructors, including part-time adjuncts, will hold advanced degrees—typically a master’s degree or a doctorate (Ph.D., Ed.D.)—in the subject they teach.
Their profiles, which should be accessible on the college’s website, will often show a combination of academic credentials and significant real-world professional experience in their field.
Rigorous Curriculum: A degree from a legitimate online program is earned, not bought. This involves a structured curriculum with clear learning objectives, substantive assignments, required reading, and assessments designed to genuinely measure a student’s knowledge.
The coursework should be challenging and require significant time and effort; it can’t be completed in a few weeks. Some programs may use proctoring services for exams to ensure academic integrity.
Credit for Prior Learning (CPL): Many legitimate colleges recognize that adult learners bring valuable knowledge from their work and life experiences. They may offer a limited amount of academic credit for this prior learning.
However, unlike a diploma mill, this isn’t a simple giveaway. It involves a rigorous evaluation process, such as passing a “challenge exam” or compiling an extensive portfolio that documents how the student’s experience meets the specific learning outcomes of a course. An entire degree is never awarded this way.
Comprehensive Student Support Services
Perhaps the most telling difference between a real school and a diploma mill is the existence of a comprehensive support ecosystem. Legitimate institutions understand that online students need a wide array of services to succeed and invest heavily in providing them.
The absence of this support infrastructure is a major red flag. A high-quality online college will offer:
Academic Support: This includes dedicated academic advisors or success coaches who help students plan their degree path and connect them with resources; online tutoring services; a virtual writing center to help with papers; and a robust online library with access to academic databases, journals, and e-books.
Technical Support: Because technology is the classroom, reliable and accessible technical support is non-negotiable. This means a dedicated help desk with extended hours (including nights and weekends) to assist students with the learning management system and other technical issues.
Administrative and Career Services: Students should have easy access to responsive financial aid counselors, registrars, and bursar’s offices. The institution should also provide career services tailored to online students, such as virtual resume workshops, online job boards, and remote career counseling.
Community and Mental Health Resources: Quality programs work to combat the isolation that online students can feel. They foster a sense of community through active discussion forums, virtual office hours with professors, online student clubs, and collaborative projects.
Furthermore, they recognize the importance of student well-being by providing access to mental health counseling and wellness resources, often through telehealth services.
Transparency in Operations
A legitimate institution operates openly and provides clear, accessible information to its students and the public.
Clear Cost Structure: The college’s website will have a clear and detailed breakdown of its tuition and fees. Tuition is typically charged on a per-credit-hour or per-term basis. Because the institution is accredited, it will be eligible to participate in federal financial aid programs and will actively encourage students to complete the FAFSA.
Transparency in Partnerships: Many universities partner with private companies called Online Program Managers (OPMs) to help them develop and run their online programs. A reputable institution should be transparent about these relationships.
Students have a right to know which aspects of their education are being handled by a third-party company and how their personal and academic data is being used and protected.
Clear Policies and Outcomes: The institution’s website should make it easy to find its student handbook, academic policies, and procedures for filing a grievance. Reputable colleges are also increasingly transparent about student outcomes, providing public data on retention rates, graduation rates, and post-graduation employment.
The key to protecting yourself from diploma mill scams is understanding that legitimate education requires time, effort, and money—but the investment pays off with a recognized credential that opens doors. If an offer seems too good to be true, it probably is. Always verify before you commit.
Our articles make government information more accessible. Please consult a qualified professional for financial, legal, or health advice specific to your circumstances.
