Last updated 3 months ago. Our resources are updated regularly but please keep in mind that links, programs, policies, and contact information do change.
Navigating the U.S. legal system can be daunting. One fundamental distinction in criminal law is whether an offense is classified as a felony or misdemeanor. This classification is based on the seriousness of the crime and potential punishments.
Felonies represent more serious criminal conduct and can lead to imprisonment for over a year, typically in a state or federal prison. Misdemeanors are considered less serious, generally resulting in jail sentences of one year or less, fines, or other non-incarceration sanctions.
Defining the Terms
The foundation of understanding criminal charges lies in the definitions of “felony” and “misdemeanor.” These terms are used throughout the United States in both federal and state legal systems.
What is a Felony?
A felony is considered a serious crime. The most common characteristic across jurisdictions is the potential for imprisonment for more than one year. This incarceration is typically served in a state or federal prison rather than a local jail.
This definition refers to the potential sentence authorized by law, not necessarily the actual sentence received. A person might be convicted of a felony but serve less than one year or even no prison time through plea agreements or judicial discretion. However, the conviction remains a felony, carrying all associated long-term consequences.
Under federal law, a felony is any offense punishable by death or imprisonment exceeding one year. Common examples include:
- Violent Crimes: Murder, manslaughter, rape, kidnapping, and aggravated assault
- Serious Property Crimes: Arson, grand theft, and burglary
- White-Collar Crimes: Embezzlement, securities fraud, and tax evasion
Felonies aren’t exclusively violent acts—crimes involving significant financial damage or deceit can also fall into this category.
What is a Misdemeanor?
A misdemeanor is a criminal offense considered less serious than a felony. The primary distinguishing factor is the potential punishment: misdemeanors are typically punishable by incarceration for one year or less. This confinement is generally served in a local or county jail rather than a state or federal prison.
In the federal system, a misdemeanor is defined as a criminal offense with a maximum imprisonment term of no more than one year. Common examples include:
- Petty Theft: Theft of items of low value (under $500 or $1,500, depending on the state)
- Simple Assault: An assault without serious injury or use of a deadly weapon
- Disorderly Conduct: Behavior that disturbs public peace
- Public Intoxication: Being drunk in public to a degree that endangers oneself or others
- Vandalism: Minor destruction or defacement of property
- Trespassing: Unlawful entry onto someone else’s property
- First-Offense DUI/DWI: Driving under the influence for the first time without aggravating factors
How Statutes Define the Difference
While the “one-year rule” serves as a widely used guideline, the definitive classification is determined by the statute—the written law—that defines the offense. The specific language of the relevant state or federal law is the supreme arbiter.
For example, the Ohio Revised Code clarifies that if an offense is specifically classified in the statute as a felony, it is a felony regardless of the penalty imposed. Only if an offense isn’t specifically classified does the potential term of imprisonment become the determining factor.
The classification can vary significantly from state to state. An act considered a misdemeanor in one state might be treated as a felony in another. Common examples include monetary thresholds for theft offenses or the quantity of a controlled substance that triggers a felony charge for possession.
Maryland law even notes that some offenses labeled as misdemeanors can carry potential sentences longer than some felonies, underscoring that the statutory label takes precedence over general sentencing expectations.
Classifying Offenses: Levels of Severity
Both federal and state legal systems further categorize crimes into different classes or degrees. These classifications reflect varying levels of severity and directly influence the potential range of punishments.
Federal Classification System
The federal government employs a structured system for classifying felonies and misdemeanors, primarily based on the maximum authorized term of imprisonment.
Federal Felony Classes (A, B, C, D, E):
Federal law (18 U.S.C. § 3559) divides felonies into five classes:
| Felony Class | Maximum Prison Term | Maximum Fine | Typical Probation Term |
|---|---|---|---|
| Class A | Life imprisonment (or death in certain cases) | $250,000 | 1-5 years |
| Class B | 25 years or more | $250,000 | 1-5 years |
| Class C | More than 10 years and less than 25 years | $250,000 | 1-5 years |
| Class D | More than 5 years and less than 10 years | $250,000 | 1-5 years |
| Class E | More than 1 year and less than 5 years | $250,000 | 1-5 years |
Federal Misdemeanor Classes (A, B, C):
Similarly, federal law categorizes misdemeanors into three classes:
| Misdemeanor Class | Maximum Prison Term | Maximum Fine | Typical Probation Term |
|---|---|---|---|
| Class A | More than 6 months and less than 1 year | $100,000 | 0-5 years |
| Class B | More than 30 days and less than 6 months | $5,000 | 0-5 years |
| Class C | More than 5 days and less than 30 days | $5,000 | 0-5 years |
Class B and C misdemeanors are sometimes referred to as “petty offenses.” Offenses carrying 5 days or less imprisonment are considered noncriminal “infractions.”
State Classification Systems
State legal systems exhibit considerable diversity in how they classify felonies and misdemeanors. While some states may use a lettered system similar to the federal model, many employ different terminologies, such as “degrees” or numbered classes. Here are examples from several states:
- Ohio: Classifies felonies by degrees, ranging from fifth degree (least serious) to first degree (most serious). Misdemeanors also have various levels, including “minor misdemeanors” which are typically punishable by a fine only.
- Maryland: State criminal statutes explicitly indicate whether an offense is a felony or a misdemeanor and list the potential penalties.
- California: Categorizes offenses into infractions (minor violations, usually fine-only), misdemeanors, and felonies. Misdemeanors are further divided into “standard misdemeanors” and “gross or aggravated misdemeanors.”
- New York: Employs a hierarchical system, classifying felonies from Class A (most serious) down to Class E, with further distinctions between “violent” and “non-violent” felonies within these classes.
- Texas: Classifies misdemeanors as Class A (most serious), Class B, and Class C (punishable by a fine up to $500).
- Washington: Classifies felonies as Class A (most serious), Class B, and Class C. Washington also differentiates between misdemeanors and “gross misdemeanors.”
Violent vs. Non-Violent Distinctions
Many states further categorize offenses, particularly felonies, as “violent” or “non-violent.” This distinction often triggers more severe penalties, such as mandatory minimum sentences, limitations on parole eligibility, and can affect the loss and potential restoration of certain civil rights.
Generally, crimes like murder, rape, armed robbery, and aggravated assault are considered violent, while offenses such as grand theft, fraud, and tax evasion are typically classified as non-violent.
Some states and the federal system recognize a level of offense below misdemeanors, often termed infractions or violations. These are typically minor breaches of the law punishable by fines only and are often not considered “crimes” in the same sense.
Potential Penalties: What’s at Stake?
The classification directly correlates with the range and severity of potential penalties. These penalties aren’t limited to incarceration but form a “punishment package” that can include financial burdens and restrictions on liberty even after release.
Incarceration
The most significant difference in penalties often lies in the potential length and location of incarceration:
Felonies: Prison vs. Jail: Felony convictions typically carry the potential for sentences of more than one year. This time is generally served in a state or federal prison. Not all individuals convicted of felonies are sentenced to prison. Judges may reserve prison sentences for violent offenses or for individuals with a history of repeat felonies.
Misdemeanors: Jail: Misdemeanor convictions usually result in sentences of up to one year, although this maximum can be lower depending on the specific class or degree of the misdemeanor and the state’s laws.
There is considerable variation across states regarding maximum incarceration lengths for misdemeanors. While 24 states cap the maximum penalty at one year of incarceration, at least six states have specific classes of misdemeanors that can be punished by more than one year in jail, with sentences going as high as five years in New Jersey and Pennsylvania.
Conversely, some states set the maximum misdemeanor jail sentence at six months or even shorter periods. A handful of states have created categories of misdemeanors that are fine-only offenses, meaning no jail time can be imposed.
Financial Penalties
Convictions for both felonies and misdemeanors can lead to significant financial burdens:
Fines: Courts routinely impose fines as part of sentencing. Felony fines are generally substantially higher than misdemeanor fines. Under federal law, most felony convictions can result in fines up to $250,000, while federal Class A misdemeanors can incur fines up to $100,000, and Class B or C misdemeanors up to $5,000.
Restitution: Judges frequently order individuals convicted of crimes to pay restitution to the victims. Restitution is intended to compensate victims for financial losses or expenses they incurred as a direct result of the crime.
Fees and Surcharges: Beyond fines and restitution, convictions often come with a host of other financial obligations. These can include court costs, fees for probation supervision, costs for mandatory drug testing or electronic monitoring, and various mandatory state surcharges.
Probation, Parole, and Supervised Release
These forms of community supervision impose conditions and restrictions on an individual’s liberty:
Felony Probation: Instead of, or sometimes in addition to, a shorter period of incarceration, a judge may sentence an individual convicted of a felony to probation. Felony probation typically lasts for several years and requires adherence to strict conditions. Failure to comply with any probation condition can lead to revocation of probation and imprisonment.
Parole and Supervised Release: These are not alternatives to prison but are forms of conditional release from prison before the full sentence has been served (parole) or a period of supervision following release from prison (supervised release).
- Parole: In states that utilize a parole system, a parole board decides whether an incarcerated individual should be released on parole, often based on their behavior while in prison and perceived readiness for reintegration.
- Supervised Release: The federal system and some states use supervised release. In this model, the judge imposes a period of supervised release at the time of sentencing, which follows the term of incarceration.
Misdemeanor Probation: Probation is a very common sentence for misdemeanor convictions. The conditions are often similar to those for felony probation, though the duration is typically shorter. Most states have statutory maximums for misdemeanor probation terms, commonly ranging from one to three years.
Habitual Offender Laws
Many states have enacted “habitual offender,” “persistent violator,” or “repeater” laws, which can dramatically increase penalties for individuals with prior convictions:
Enhanced Penalties: These laws mean that a person convicted of a new offense, who has a history of prior convictions, can face significantly more severe penalties than would typically apply to the current offense alone.
Misdemeanors Charged as Felonies: In some jurisdictions, habitual misdemeanor offending can trigger an escalation where a current misdemeanor charge is elevated to a felony. This is common for offenses like DUI/DWI, where multiple prior convictions can turn a subsequent DUI into a felony.
For example, in Wisconsin, an individual classified as a “repeater” for having three separate misdemeanor convictions within a five-year period may have the maximum one-year sentence for a subsequent misdemeanor increased to up to two years of incarceration.
The Legal Journey: Procedural Differences
The path a criminal case takes through the justice system often differs significantly depending on whether the charge is a felony or a misdemeanor. These procedural distinctions reflect the varying levels of seriousness and the potential consequences associated with each type of offense.
Initiating Charges
The way criminal charges are formally brought against an individual varies:
Felonies: Given their gravity, felony cases typically begin with a formal criminal complaint filed by a prosecutor. In the federal system and many states, this initial step is often followed by a grand jury indictment. A grand jury reviews evidence presented by the prosecution in secret to determine if there is sufficient probable cause to issue formal charges.
Misdemeanors: The initiation of misdemeanor charges is often less formal. For minor offenses, law enforcement officers may issue a citation or violation notice directly to the individual. For other misdemeanors, a prosecutor may file a document called a criminal information directly with the court, outlining the charges.
Key Court Appearances
Several court appearances are standard in the criminal process, with some variations for felonies and misdemeanors:
Initial Appearance: This is the defendant’s first appearance before a judge, typically occurring shortly after an arrest. During this hearing, the defendant is formally advised of the charges and their constitutional rights. Arrangements for legal representation are made, and the judge makes a determination regarding bail or other conditions of pretrial release.
Preliminary Hearing: This hearing is a critical stage primarily for felony cases. Its purpose is for a judge to review the prosecution’s evidence and determine if there is sufficient probable cause to believe that the defendant committed the crime charged. If the judge finds probable cause, the case proceeds toward trial.
Arraignment: Following the formal filing of charges, the defendant is arraigned. At the arraignment, the defendant is officially informed of the charges and is asked to enter a plea. Common pleas are “guilty,” “not guilty,” or “no contest.”
Right to a Jury Trial
The right to a trial by a jury of one’s peers is a cornerstone of the American justice system, but its application can vary:
- Defendants facing felony charges generally have a constitutional right to a jury trial.
- For misdemeanors, the right to a jury trial is not always guaranteed. Specifically, for offenses classified as “petty offenses”—typically those punishable by six months or less of incarceration—there may not be a constitutional right to a jury trial.
Judges and Courts
The judicial officers and court structures handling cases can also differ:
Federal Misdemeanors: In the federal system, misdemeanor cases are often handled by U.S. Magistrate Judges rather than U.S. District Judges, who typically preside over felony trials.
State Courts: Some states have distinct court levels for misdemeanors and felonies, reflecting the hierarchical nature of offense severity. For instance, North Carolina primarily handles misdemeanor cases in District Court, while more serious felony cases and all felony trials are resolved in Superior Court.
Sentencing Process
The procedures and considerations involved in sentencing can also vary:
Felony Sentencing: Sentencing for felony convictions is often a more complex process. It may involve the preparation of a detailed pre-sentence investigation report by a probation office, which provides the judge with extensive background information about the defendant and the offense.
Misdemeanor Sentencing: While judges must still sentence within the statutory maximums for the offense, they may have more discretion in misdemeanor sentencing. Formal pre-sentence reports may not be ordered, and comprehensive sentencing guidelines may not apply to less serious misdemeanors.
The following table summarizes some key procedural differences:
| Procedural Step | Typical Felony Process | Typical Misdemeanor Process | Key Distinctions/Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Initiating Charges | Criminal complaint, often followed by Grand Jury Indictment. | Citation, violation notice, or Criminal Information filed by prosecutor. | Felonies involve more formal charging, often with citizen review (grand jury). Misdemeanors are more streamlined. |
| Grand Jury / Prelim. Hearing | Grand Jury Indictment OR Preliminary Hearing to establish probable cause. | Generally not applicable; charges proceed directly on information/citation. | These are significant pre-trial hurdles for felony cases to ensure sufficient evidence. Grand juries are secret & non-adversarial; prelim. hearings are open & adversarial. |
| Right to Jury Trial | Generally guaranteed. | May not apply to “petty offenses” (e.g., punishable by ≤ 6 months jail); judge trial. | The stakes are higher in felony cases, warranting fuller jury trial rights. |
| Handling Judge/Court | Often handled by higher-level trial court judges (e.g., U.S. District Judge, State Superior Court Judge). | May be handled by lower-level judges (e.g., U.S. Magistrate Judge, State District Court Judge). | Court structure can reflect the severity and complexity of the cases. |
| Sentencing Considerations | Often involves pre-sentence reports, adherence to sentencing guidelines. | More judicial discretion, less formal pre-sentence process, guidelines may not apply. | Felony sentencing is typically more structured due to the severity of potential penalties. |
Beyond the Sentence: Long-Term Collateral Consequences
A criminal conviction carries consequences that extend far beyond any court-imposed sentence of incarceration, fines, or probation. These are known as collateral consequences: a vast array of legal and regulatory sanctions and restrictions that can profoundly alter an individual’s life, opportunities, and societal standing.
The National Inventory of Collateral Consequences of Conviction (NICCC) has cataloged nearly 44,000 such state and federal consequences. An estimated 70 to 100 million Americans—or roughly one in three adults—have a criminal record and are thus potentially affected by these pervasive restrictions.
Impact on Civil Rights
Fundamental civic rights can be curtailed or lost entirely following a criminal conviction, especially a felony:
Voting Rights: A felony conviction can lead to disenfranchisement—the loss of the right to vote. The rules governing this vary dramatically by state. Some states restore voting rights automatically upon release from incarceration or completion of sentence. Others impose waiting periods, require a separate application process, or mandate the payment of all fines, fees, and restitution before rights are restored. The Collateral Consequences Resource Center provides detailed state-by-state information.
Jury Service: The ability to serve on a jury is commonly lost upon a felony conviction. Similar to voting rights, the rules for restoration differ by state, with some requiring a pardon or a specific waiting period after sentence completion.
Firearm Possession: Federal law, notably 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1), prohibits individuals convicted of a crime punishable by imprisonment for a term exceeding one year (the definition of a felony) from possessing firearms. Many states have parallel laws.
Barriers to Opportunities
Collateral consequences create formidable obstacles in numerous areas essential for a stable and productive life:
Employment and Professional Licensing: This is one of the most significant areas of impact. A criminal record, particularly a felony, can be a major impediment to securing employment, as many employers conduct background checks. Furthermore, individuals with convictions may be barred from obtaining or maintaining professional licenses required for many occupations, such as those in healthcare, law, real estate, education, and skilled trades.
These barriers contribute to higher rates of unemployment and underemployment among individuals with criminal records, leading to significant economic losses for both the individuals and society as a whole—estimated at $57 billion to $65 billion annually in reduced economic output. These consequences also disproportionately affect people of color, who are overrepresented in the criminal justice system.
Housing: Securing safe and affordable housing can become extremely difficult. Landlords and public housing authorities often conduct background checks, and a criminal record can be grounds for denial of a rental application or eviction. This can lead to housing instability and homelessness.
Education: While recent federal changes have removed drug convictions as an automatic barrier to federal student aid eligibility, a criminal record can still pose challenges in gaining admission to educational institutions or specific programs. It is advisable to complete the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA®) form, as many schools and states use this information for nonfederal aid, which might still be available.
Public Benefits: Eligibility for various federal and state public benefits, such as Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) or Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), can be restricted or denied based on certain convictions, particularly drug felonies.
Immigration Status: For non-U.S. citizens, the immigration consequences of a criminal conviction can be particularly severe. Many felony convictions, and even certain misdemeanors, can lead to detention, deportation, denial of re-entry, or ineligibility for lawful permanent residence or naturalization.
Other Impacts: The reach of collateral consequences extends further, potentially affecting an individual’s ability to obtain or retain a security clearance, maintain a driver’s license, secure loans or credit, exercise parental rights, or even participate in volunteer activities within their communities.
Mandatory vs. Discretionary Consequences
Collateral consequences can be broadly categorized based on how they are imposed:
Collateral Sanctions: These are mandatory consequences that are imposed automatically by operation of law upon conviction for a specific offense. For example, in many states, the loss of the right to vote or the right to possess a firearm for individuals convicted of felonies are collateral sanctions.
Disqualifications: These are discretionary consequences. This means that an entity (such as an employer, licensing board, or housing provider) is authorized by law to impose the restriction or denial based on a conviction but is not required to do so.
Impact of Misdemeanor Convictions
While the most severe and numerous collateral consequences are typically associated with felony convictions, it is a dangerous misconception to assume that misdemeanor convictions are trivial or without lasting impact. Misdemeanor convictions can also lead to significant long-term problems that affect an individual’s life and livelihood.
These can include:
- Employment Difficulties: While perhaps not as universally barring as felonies, misdemeanors can still result in job loss or difficulty finding new employment, as they appear on background checks.
- Professional Licensing Issues: Certain misdemeanors can impact the ability to obtain or retain professional licenses, particularly if the offense is deemed to reflect on the individual’s character, trustworthiness, or fitness to practice in that profession.
- Housing Challenges: Landlords may still deny rental applications based on misdemeanor convictions.
- Immigration Consequences: Certain misdemeanors, such as those considered “crimes involving moral turpitude” by immigration authorities, can have serious immigration consequences for non-citizens.
- Other Stigmas: Even federal misdemeanors can lead to loss of security clearances, suspension of driving privileges, and the general stigma of having a criminal record, which can affect personal relationships and social standing.
Restoration of Rights, Expungement, and Sealing Records
Recognizing the often disproportionate and lifelong impact of collateral consequences, many states and the federal government have established mechanisms aimed at mitigating some of these effects and promoting successful reentry into society:
Restoration of Civil Rights: Many jurisdictions have processes for restoring civil rights lost due to a conviction, such as the right to vote, serve on a jury, or possess firearms. These processes are often complex and differ significantly by state and by the specific right in question.
Expungement and Sealing of Records: Expungement generally refers to a legal process that results in the “destruction” or deletion of criminal records, treating the conviction (or arrest) as if it never occurred for most purposes. Sealing records typically removes them from public view, meaning they still exist but can only be accessed under limited, legally defined circumstances.
Organizations like the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL) and the Clean Slate Clearinghouse track legislative efforts in this area.
“Wobblers”: When an Offense Can Be Either
In the landscape of criminal law, not all offenses fit neatly into the fixed categories of felony or misdemeanor from the outset. Some crimes occupy a gray area and are known as “wobblers.” These offenses can be treated as either a felony or a misdemeanor, depending on a range of factors, including the specific details of the crime and the discretion exercised by prosecutors and judges.
Examples of Common Wobblers
The types of crimes designated as wobblers vary by state. However, some common examples include:
- Assault with a deadly weapon (that isn’t a firearm, in some jurisdictions)
- Vehicular manslaughter (unintentional killing with a vehicle)
- Grand theft (theft of property above a certain value, where the value is near the felony threshold)
- Forgery
- Stalking
- Child endangerment
- Domestic violence (depending on the severity of injury and prior history)
- Drug possession (where the amount or type of drug, or prior drug offenses, are determining factors)
- Driving Under the Influence (DUI/DWI), especially with prior convictions or aggravating factors
Factors Influencing Charging and Sentencing Decisions
The decision to classify a wobbler as a felony or a misdemeanor is not arbitrary. It is typically based on a careful evaluation of several factors by both prosecutors (when initially filing charges) and judges (at various stages, including sentencing or later petitions).
Key factors considered in these decisions include:
- Severity of the Offense: The specific nature and circumstances of the crime are paramount. This includes the degree of harm or loss caused to the victim, whether a weapon was used, and the overall dangerousness of the defendant’s conduct.
- Defendant’s Criminal History: An individual’s prior criminal record plays a significant role. A defendant with no prior convictions, or only minor ones, is more likely to have a wobbler treated as a misdemeanor.
- Aggravating or Mitigating Factors: Aggravating factors can push a wobbler towards a felony classification. Mitigating factors can support a misdemeanor classification.
- Impact on the Victim: The extent of physical, emotional, or financial harm suffered by the victim is an important consideration.
- State Laws and Legal Precedents: The specific statutes in the jurisdiction define which offenses are wobblers and may provide guidance on the factors to consider.
The existence of wobbler offenses underscores that the boundary between a felony and a misdemeanor is not always rigid. It highlights the significant role of discretion within the justice system, allowing for a more individualized assessment of culpability and potential for rehabilitation.
Reducing Felonies to Misdemeanors: A Pathway for Reclassification
Some states have enacted specific statutory mechanisms that allow for certain felony convictions (particularly those that were wobblers) to be formally reduced to misdemeanors. A well-known example is California Penal Code § 17(b). This law grants California courts the authority to declare a wobbler offense a misdemeanor under several circumstances:
- At the initial charge, if the prosecutor files it as a misdemeanor.
- At the preliminary hearing, if the magistrate determines it should be a misdemeanor.
- At the time of sentencing, if the court imposes a punishment other than state prison.
- After successful completion of felony probation, if the court grants a petition to reduce the felony to a misdemeanor.
Such provisions offer a formal pathway for individuals to have the classification of their offense changed, even after conviction. This reclassification can be immensely beneficial, as it can alleviate many of the severe long-term collateral consequences associated with a felony record.
“Wobblettes”
A related but less common term is “wobblette.” This refers to an offense that can be charged as either a misdemeanor or an even lesser offense, such as an infraction (a minor violation typically punishable only by a fine and not considered a crime). Like wobblers, the classification of a wobblette depends on prosecutorial and judicial discretion and the specifics of the case.
Understanding the concept of wobblers is crucial because it reveals that the initial label of “felony” or “misdemeanor” for certain crimes is not always fixed. The context of the offense, the background of the individual, and the decisions made by prosecutors and judges all play a vital role in determining the ultimate classification and, consequently, the long-term impact on a person’s life.
Our articles make government information more accessible. Please consult a qualified professional for financial, legal, or health advice specific to your circumstances.
